Rogers vs Garner

FPL Comparison · GW38 · Who to buy?

Quick answer: Buy Rogers over Garner this week. Rogers edges it on: stronger captain verdict (STRONG), higher projected xP (3.7), better recent form (4.2).

Buy Rogers over Garner this week.

Rogers edges it on: stronger captain verdict (STRONG), higher projected xP (3.7), better recent form (4.2).

✓ Recommended pick
Rogers
Aston Villa
MID£7.3m21.0% owned
10
Goals
8
Assists
169
Points
Engine verdict:STRONG
Next: @ MCI · D5/5 · 3.7 xP
Full profile →
Garner
Everton
MID£5.2m3.8% owned
2
Goals
7
Assists
155
Points
Engine verdict:AVOID
Next: @ TOT · D3/5 · 2.5 xP
Full profile →

Head-to-Head Stats

Rogers (A) vs Garner (B) — ✓ marks the better value
AStatB
£7.3mPrice£5.2m
21.0%Ownership3.8%
169Total points155
10Goals2
8Assists7
17Bonus points13
4.2Form (last 30 days)2.5
5.2Avg pts last 5 GWs2.6
3.7Next fixture xP2.5
3.76-GW projected xP2.5
6.8xG this season2.0
4.3xA this season5.9

Recent Form — Last 5 Gameweeks

Rogers
9
2
1
2
12
Garner
3
3
5
1
1

Upcoming Fixture Difficulty

Rogers
MCI
Garner
TOT
Easy (D1–2) Medium (D3) Hard (D4) Very hard (D5)

Rogers vs Garner — Common Questions

Should I buy Rogers or Garner in FPL?

Buy Rogers over Garner this week. Rogers edges it on: stronger captain verdict (STRONG), higher projected xP (3.7), better recent form (4.2). Rogers costs £7.3m and Garner costs £5.2m — the price gap is £2.1m.

Rogers or Garner — who should I captain GW38?

Onside recommends Rogers as the captain pick for GW38 (STRONG). Rogers edges it on: stronger captain verdict (STRONG), higher projected xP (3.7), better recent form (4.2).

How do Rogers and Garner compare statistically?

This season: Rogers has 10 goals + 8 assists (169 pts, £7.3m). Garner has 2 goals + 7 assists (155 pts, £5.2m). Rogers lead on goal involvements.

Who has the better fixture — Rogers or Garner?

GW38: Rogers plays @ MCI (D5) and Garner plays @ TOT (D3). Garner has the easier fixture.

Do Rogers or Garner take set pieces?

Rogers does not take set pieces. Garner takes free kicks and corners for Everton.

Explore More

Comparison data sourced from Fantasy Premier League API. Verdicts computed by the Onside v5 engine with Monte Carlo simulation. Refreshes every hour via ISR.