Scarlett vs Casey

FPL Comparison · this week · Who to buy?

Quick answer: Buy Casey over Scarlett this week. Casey edges it on: stronger captain verdict (AVOID).

Buy Casey over Scarlett this week.

Casey edges it on: stronger captain verdict (AVOID).

FWD£4.3m0.5% owned
0
Goals
0
Assists
2
Points
Engine verdict:UNAVAILABLE
has joined Hibernian on loan for the rest of the season.
Full profile →
✓ Recommended pick
Casey
Crystal Palace
FWD£4.5m0.0% owned
0
Goals
0
Assists
0
Points
Engine verdict:AVOID
Full profile →

Head-to-Head Stats

Scarlett (A) vs Casey (B) — ✓ marks the better value
AStatB
£4.3mPrice£4.5m
0.5%Ownership0.0%
2Total points0
0Goals0
0Assists0
0Bonus points0
0.0Form (last 30 days)0.0
0.0Avg pts last 5 GWs0.0
Next fixture xP
6-GW projected xP
0.0xG this season0.0
0.0xA this season0.0

Recent Form — Last 5 Gameweeks

Scarlett
0
0
0
0
0
Casey
0
0
0
0
0

Upcoming Fixture Difficulty

Scarlett
No upcoming fixtures
Casey
No upcoming fixtures
Easy (D1–2) Medium (D3) Hard (D4) Very hard (D5)

Scarlett vs Casey — Common Questions

Should I buy Scarlett or Casey in FPL?

Buy Casey over Scarlett this week. Casey edges it on: stronger captain verdict (AVOID). Scarlett costs £4.3m and Casey costs £4.5m — the price gap is £0.2m.

Scarlett or Casey — who should I captain this gameweek?

Onside recommends Casey as the captain pick for this gameweek (AVOID). Casey edges it on: stronger captain verdict (AVOID).

How do Scarlett and Casey compare statistically?

This season: Scarlett has 0 goals + 0 assists (2 pts, £4.3m). Casey has 0 goals + 0 assists (0 pts, £4.5m). Both players lead equally on goal involvements.

Do Scarlett or Casey take set pieces?

Neither Scarlett nor Casey are listed as primary set-piece takers in Onside's current data.

Explore More

Comparison data sourced from Fantasy Premier League API. Verdicts computed by the Onside v5 engine with Monte Carlo simulation. Refreshes every hour via ISR.

Scarlett vs Casey FPL 2026-27 — Who to Buy? | Onside · Onside