FPL comparison · GW12

Calafiori vs Silva

— who to buy for GW12?

Calafiori
ARS · Defender
Calafiori
Price
£5.9m
xP
3.3
Owned
48.5%
Silva
BOU · Defender
Silva
Price
£5.1m
xP
3.8
Owned
4.0%
The model's pick
Verdict

Buy Silva over Calafiori this week.

Silva edges it on: easier next fixture (difficulty 3/5), higher projected xP (3.8), better recent form (6.8).

Decided on Silva? Finish the job:

Calafiori
Arsenal
DEF£5.9m48.5% owned
1
Goals
2
Assists
58
Points
Captain verdict:STRONG
Next: vs MCI · D4/5 · 3.3 xP
Full profile →
✓ Recommended pick
Silva
Bournemouth
DEF£5.1m4.0% owned
0
Goals
0
Assists
48
Points
Captain verdict:STRONG
Next: @ FUL · D3/5 · 3.8 xP
Full profile →

Head-to-Head Stats

Calafiori (A) vs Silva (B) — ✓ marks the better value
AStatB
£5.9mPrice✓£5.1m
48.5%Ownership4.0%
58✓Total points48
1✓Goals0
2✓Assists0
6✓Clean sheets4
3Bonus points3
3.5Form (last 30 days)✓6.8
4.0Avg pts last 5 GWs✓7.0
3.3Next fixture xP✓3.8
17.36-GW projected xP✓19.8
1.3xG this season✓1.4
1.0✓xA this season0.5

Recent Form — Last 5 Gameweeks

Calafiori
6
1
6
6
1
Silva
8
8
8
3
8

Upcoming Fixture Difficulty

Calafiori
MCI
BRE
TOT
BOU
MUN
CRY
Silva
FUL
BHA
HUL
ARS
COV
TOT
Easy (D1–2) Medium (D3) Hard (D4) Very hard (D5)

Calafiori vs Silva — Common Questions

Should I buy Calafiori or Silva in FPL?

Buy Silva over Calafiori this week. Silva edges it on: easier next fixture (difficulty 3/5), higher projected xP (3.8), better recent form (6.8). Calafiori costs £5.9m and Silva costs £5.1m — the price gap is £0.8m.

Calafiori or Silva — who should I captain GW12?

Onside recommends Silva as the captain pick for GW12. Silva edges it on: easier next fixture (difficulty 3/5), higher projected xP (3.8), better recent form (6.8).

How do Calafiori and Silva compare statistically?

This season: Calafiori has 1 goals + 2 assists (58 pts, £5.9m). Silva has 0 goals + 0 assists (48 pts, £5.1m). Calafiori lead on goal involvements.

Who has the better fixture — Calafiori or Silva?

GW12: Calafiori plays vs MCI (D4) and Silva plays @ FUL (D3). Silva has the easier fixture.

Do Calafiori or Silva take set pieces?

Neither Calafiori nor Silva are listed as primary set-piece takers in Onside's current data.

Explore More

Compare Calafiori against:

Comparison data sourced from Fantasy Premier League API. Verdicts computed by the Onside engine. Data refreshes continuously.